Policy spillovers from climate actions to energy poverty: international evidence

Policy spillovers from climate actions to energy poverty: international evidence

Climate change has become one of the most pressing issues facing the global community, and Europe has been at the forefront of the transition to renewable energy and decarbonization. As countries strive to meet their net-zero emissions goals, policymakers are implementing a range of measures, from wind energy expansions and solar power breakthroughs to hydrogen pilot projects and innovative battery storage solutions. However, the impacts of these climate actions extend beyond emissions reductions, with potential spillover effects on other critical issues, such as energy poverty.

Energy poverty, a key component of the UN’s Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), remains a significant challenge, particularly in developing nations. Addressing this multifaceted problem requires a comprehensive approach that integrates policy mechanisms, public-private partnerships, and innovative financing solutions. Interestingly, the relationship between climate policies and energy poverty is complex, with both positive and negative implications. ​

This article examines the international evidence on the policy spillovers from climate actions to energy poverty, drawing insights from a range of countries and policy experiences. By analyzing cross-country data from 2000 to 2020, we uncover the nuanced ways in which climate policies can impact energy development and access, providing policymakers with a more holistic understanding of the potential synergies and trade-offs involved.

Defining Climate Actions

At the core of climate policies lies the objective of controlling greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, which primarily stem from the consumption of fossil fuels. Consequently, the implementation of climate policies can affect various energy-related issues, including energy poverty. These policies take diverse forms, from legislative measures and regulations to strategic initiatives and executive orders.

Globally, the number of climate policies has been steadily increasing, with over 70 carbon pricing initiatives and more than 110 countries committing to carbon-neutral targets. Europe has been particularly active in this domain, with a range of policies aimed at accelerating the energy transition, promoting renewable energy sources, and supporting innovation in clean technologies.

Impacts of Climate Actions

The impacts of climate policies on energy poverty can be both positive and negative. On the one hand, climate actions can contribute to the development of renewable energy, improve energy efficiency, and channel climate finance to support the energy sector, ultimately benefiting energy-poor communities. On the other hand, poorly designed climate policies, such as carbon taxes or environmental restrictions, can inadvertently increase energy prices, exacerbating affordability issues.

Recent studies have highlighted the complex and sometimes contradictory findings on the relationship between climate policies and energy poverty. Some researchers have found that green fiscal policies can reduce energy poverty by improving efficiency, while others have argued that ambitious climate mitigation scenarios may not fundamentally change energy access for households in developing countries.

Factors Influencing Policy Spillovers

The effectiveness of climate policies in addressing energy poverty depends on several factors, including the policy type, policy duration, and the level of economic development in the target country.

Legislative policies, for instance, have been shown to have stronger spillover effects compared to executive-level policies. Additionally, long-term climate policies tend to be more effective in alleviating energy poverty than short-term measures. Furthermore, the impacts of climate policies are generally more pronounced in developing countries, where energy poverty is more prevalent and the potential for improvement is greater.

Importantly, the mechanisms through which climate policies influence energy poverty include improving energy efficiency, promoting renewable energy, and supporting innovation. By channeling climate finance towards these areas, policymakers can unlock synergies between climate action and energy access goals.

Energy Poverty: Global Perspectives

Conceptualizing Energy Poverty

The concept of energy poverty can be traced back to the work of Lewis (1982), who highlighted the impact of insufficient energy use on human well-being. Over time, the definition has evolved to incorporate energy access alongside affordability, reflecting the multidimensional nature of this issue.

Broader measures of energy poverty, such as the Energy Development Index (EDI), have been developed to capture factors like total primary energy use, renewable energy consumption, electricity access, and electric power consumption at the national level. These comprehensive indicators provide a more nuanced understanding of energy poverty across countries.

Determinants of Energy Poverty

In addition to climate policies, a range of socio-economic factors have been identified as influencing energy poverty, including economic development, trade openness, industrial structure, urbanization, labor force participation, and age dependency ratio. These variables, along with climate-related factors like abnormal temperatures, shape the energy poverty landscape and the potential for policy interventions.

Measuring Energy Poverty

Measuring energy poverty at the national level is crucial for understanding the scale of the challenge and the effectiveness of policy interventions. The EDI, developed by Banerjee et al. (2021), has emerged as a widely used metric that captures the multidimensional nature of energy poverty. By aggregating information on energy access, affordability, and sustainability, the EDI provides a comprehensive assessment of a country’s energy development status.

Policy Implications

Addressing Energy Poverty

The findings from this research highlight the potential for climate policies to contribute to the alleviation of energy poverty. By recognizing the positive spillover effects, policymakers can be motivated to adopt more ambitious climate actions, as these can generate broader societal benefits beyond emissions reductions.

Integrating Climate and Energy Policies

However, the impacts of climate policies are not uniform, and policymakers must carefully consider the design and implementation of these measures. Integrating energy poverty concerns into climate policy frameworks can help create synergies and avoid unintended consequences, such as increased energy prices.

Ensuring Equitable Transitions

The differential impacts of climate policies on developed and developing countries underscore the importance of tailoring policy approaches to local contexts. Ensuring an equitable energy transition that benefits all segments of the population, particularly the most vulnerable, should be a key priority for policymakers.

International Evidence

Case Studies

The European experience offers valuable insights into the potential policy spillovers from climate actions to energy poverty. Countries like Germany, Denmark, and the Netherlands have implemented a range of climate policies, including renewable energy targets, carbon pricing, and green innovation incentives, which have contributed to improvements in energy access and affordability.

Cross-country Comparisons

Analyzing cross-country data reveals nuanced relationships between climate policies and energy poverty. While the overall trend shows a positive spillover effect, the strength of the impact varies depending on the policy type, duration, and the level of economic development. Developing countries, in particular, have experienced more significant benefits from climate policies in addressing energy poverty.

Policy Lessons

The international evidence suggests that policymakers should prioritize legislative policies, long-term measures, and a balanced policy mix that combines regulations, strategies, and support for innovation. By aligning climate and energy policies, governments can harness the synergies and ensure a more inclusive and sustainable energy transition.

The European Future Energy Forum provides a valuable platform for policymakers, industry leaders, and experts to share best practices and collaborate on addressing the complex challenges at the intersection of climate action and energy poverty. By leveraging the insights from this international evidence, the Forum can inform the development of effective policy frameworks and innovative solutions to drive progress towards a more equitable and sustainable energy future.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn